What
interested me most about The
Saber-Tooth Curriculum is that even though it was written in 1939, the
views about education and where it is heading are still VERY relevant today (70
years later!). I also found the fact that the story was written using the
Paleolithic era and a lot of satire made the story appear to be way ahead of its
time! At no time that I was reading it did I feel like it was a story from
1939.
After
reading and reviewing the book, I learned that education is important because
children need to learn to find ways to enrich their lives, not only for
themselves, but also for the benefit of the society in which they live.
Education's purpose is to teach students to prepare for their future in the
work force and security. They learn to become better and more informed
citizens. Education also unifies people into cohesive communities. Students
need real, relevant experiences to understand what they are being taught.
However, changing the way students are taught or how teachers teach is not
always received well by others. Especially if they feel that sticking to the
fundamentals is better than changing education to fit with how society is ever
changing. The Elders (conservative tribesmen) in the book view changes in
education merely "training" and not education due to their tribe traditions
(fish-grabbing, woolly horse clubbing, and saber-tooth tiger scaring) and their
"magical" beliefs. Despite the changes in the needs of all tribe
members, the Elders felt that the basis of education should not change. Those
concepts worked, so why should they be changed. One stated, “The essence of true education is timelessness. It is
something that endures through changing conditions like a solid rock standing
squarely and firmly in the middle of a raging torrent. You must know that there
are some eternal verities, and the saber-tooth curriculum is one of them!” (p.
44). The Radicals thought the Elders were crazy, and
the education system needed to be updated, however, their hands were tied
because all the decisions came from the Elders in regards to educating the
tribe. When a tribe teacher questioned the other tribe teachers about how
education should have a clear goal in mind that will modify the students’
behavior so they learn another system for hunting and fishing so they don't
starve to death, the other tribe teachers stated that, “’We can teach them how to think, not what to think.” (p.109). This is still an ongoing
problem today, and I believe it will be for as long as we educate our children
in public schools.
The second design goal, PICKLE (P=problem
solving, I=information using, C=community participation, K=knowledge,
L=literate, and E=ethical decision making), is the basis for 21st
century learning. Like New-Fist wanted to prepare his tribe’s children to have
security and be prepared for the work force of fish grabbing, woolly-horse
clubbing, and saber-tooth-tiger scaring, the same principles for PICKLE are
what we need to prepare our students for their security and workforce
readiness.
Each principle that makes up PICKLE is
essential for 21st century learners. Though students may be stronger
in one principle that the others, they still need to be able to draw on each
principle in order to succeed. These principles are not inherent. Students need
to learn them just like any skill they learned. Our job as 21st century
teachers is to design lessons in which students not only learn the PICKLE
principles, but can take what they learn and apply it in their every-day lives.
You are so right! "Sticking to the fundamentals" is so much easier than redesigning a system to fit an "ever-changing" society. So much of the resistance that we see from teachers and administrators when it comes to education reform stems from the frustration of reinventing (or what feels like reinventing) the wheel. What's important is to remember that teaching using the PICKLE will always be valuable instruction, regardless of fads and trends. Great post!
ReplyDeleteIt was surprising to think how relevant this book still is today! As I was reading I kept thinking back to my own education and if what I was taught was just for "magic". I agree that change is frighting and moving our education system in a different direction is going to be difficult but our students will benefit so much more. They definitely need the PICKLE to be successful in the workforce.
ReplyDeleteI too am shocked, and a little ashamed, of the timelessness of this book. I truly hope people WON'T be reading it again in 70 years because it no longer reflects how education works.
ReplyDeleteDespite the message of the book, I do agree that teaching kids how to think is more important than what to think. But I feel this is different than teaching kids how to think and what to KNOW (as opposed to think). And you can teach kids how to think while making sure they know what they need to know in order to be prepared for the world we live in.